Why do clients use them?
To bring construction knowledge into the design while it is still cheap to change, and to start work on long lead items before every detail is settled. On grid connection and substation projects, where transformer and switchgear lead times can drive the whole programme, that second reason often decides it.
The client gives up the price tension of a single stage competition in exchange for seeing how the price is built.
What changes for the estimator?
In stage one, most of what you submit is not a price for the works. It is a fee, a preliminaries build up, a margin, and a set of rates that will govern the stage two negotiation. Those rates are the most consequential numbers in the whole process, and they are usually set before anyone knows the final scope.
In stage two, you are converting to a fixed price on a design you influenced, which removes the excuse of not having understood the scope. The upside is real: buildability improvements, early procurement of long lead plant, and risk allocated with your input rather than discovered afterwards.
Where does it go wrong?
At conversion. If stage two has no agreed method for arriving at the price, or no honest fallback when the parties cannot agree, the contractor has invested months of engineering into a project that may still walk away, and the client has lost competitive tension without gaining certainty.
The other failure is quieter: stage one rates that no longer make sense against the scope that emerged. Check what governs if the design grows well beyond the assumptions those rates were built on.
Single stage against two stage
| Single stage | Two stage with ECI | |
|---|---|---|
| What you price at selection | The full works, from a completed design | A fee, preliminaries, margin and governing rates |
| Design maturity when price fixes | High, but developed without you | Higher in buildability terms, and shaped with you |
| Where the risk sits | In what the design got wrong before you saw it | In the stage two conversion, and in the stage one rates |
| Long lead procurement | Starts after award | Can start during stage one |
| What to check first | Order of precedence and scope conflicts | The conversion mechanism and what happens if it fails |